A Mind of Its Own by David M. Friedman
A Cultural History of the Penis

No critic rating

Waiting for minimum critic reviews

See 4 Critic Reviews



Whether enemy or ally, demon or god, the source of satisfaction or the root of all earthly troubles, the penis has forced humanity to wrestle with its enduring mysteries. Here, in an enlightening and entertaining cultural study, is a book that gives context to the central role of the penis in Western civilization.

A man can hold his manhood in his hand, but who is really gripping whom? Is the penis the best in man -- or the beast? How is man supposed to use it? And when does that use become abuse? Of all the bodily organs, only the penis forces man to confront such contradictions: something insistent yet reluctant, a tool that creates but also destroys, a part of the body that often seems apart from the body. This is the conundrum that makes the penis both hero and villain in a drama that shapes every man -- and mankind along with it.

In A Mind of Its Own, David M. Friedman shows that the penis is more than a body part. It is an idea, a conceptual but flesh-and-blood measuring stick of man's place in the world. That men have a penis is a scientific fact; how they think about it, feel about it, and use it is not. It is possible to identify the key moments in Western history when a new idea of the penis addressed the larger mystery of man's relationship with it and changed forever the way that organ was conceived of and put to use. A Mind of Its Own brilliantly distills this complex and largely unexamined story.

Deified by the pagan cultures of the ancient world and demonized by the early Roman church, the organ was later secularized by pioneering anatomists such as Leonardo da Vinci. After being measured "scientifically" in an effort to subjugate some races while elevating others, the organ was psychoanalyzed by Sigmund Freud. As a result, the penis assumed a paradigmatic role in psychology -- whether the patient was equipped with the organ or envied those who were. Now, after being politicized by feminism and exploited in countless ways by pop culture, the penis has been medicalized. As no one has before him, Friedman shows how the arrival of erection industry products such as Viagra is more than a health or business story. It is the latest -- and perhaps final -- chapter in one of the longest sagas in human history: the story of man's relationship with his penis.

A Mind of Its Own charts the vicissitudes of that relationship through its often amusing, occasionally alarming, and never boring course. With intellectual rigor and a healthy dose of wry humor, David M. Friedman serves up one of the most thought-provoking, significant, and readable cultural works in years.

About David M. Friedman

See more books from this Author
David M. Friedman has written for Esquire, GQ, Rolling Stone, Vogue, The Village Voice, and many other publications. He has been a reporter for Newsday and the Philadelphia Daily News.
Published September 4, 2008 by Free Press. 368 pages
Genres: Health, Fitness & Dieting, Political & Social Sciences, History, Professional & Technical. Non-fiction

Unrated Critic Reviews for A Mind of Its Own

Kirkus Reviews

See more reviews from this publication

By contrast, physician Giles Brindley suffered no such embarrassment when, in 1983, he trotted his own medically enhanced erection through a throng of urologists at a Las Vegas medical convention, leading the charge for medically sanctioned tumescence and corporate cash.

| Read Full Review of A Mind of Its Own: A Cultural...

The New York Times

See more reviews from this publication

But ''A Mind of Its Own'' keeps up interest, especially in a packed chapter recounting the many pseudoscientists who have gathered ''phallometric data'' to attempt to prove penis size is related to race -- a question Friedman calls ''unanswered, and maybe unanswerable.'' The final chapter is devo...

Jan 13 2002 | Read Full Review of A Mind of Its Own: A Cultural...

The Guardian

See more reviews from this publication

These phases one might summarise as the age of the supernatural or religious penis, the age of the scientific penis, the imperial and racist penis, the psychological penis, the ideological penis, and our current phase or age, what we might call the age of the leisure or entertainment penis.

Nov 09 2002 | Read Full Review of A Mind of Its Own: A Cultural...

Publishers Weekly

See more reviews from this publication

"Over time, the penis has been deified, demonized, secularized, racialized, psychoanalyzed, politicized and, finally, medicalized," declares freelance journalist Friedman in a serious yet entertaining book that weaves together an enormous amount of material.

| Read Full Review of A Mind of Its Own: A Cultural...

Reader Rating for A Mind of Its Own

An aggregated and normalized score based on 38 user ratings from iDreamBooks & iTunes

Rate this book!

Add Review