Aelian's On the Nature of Animals by Gregory McNamee

No critic rating

Waiting for minimum critic reviews

See 1 Critic Review

My second quarrel is with an attitude prevalent in many contemporary books on nature. It isn't enough to enjoy the world about us, and delight in its beauty. No, we have to take one particular lesson...
-WSJ online


Not much can be said with certainty about the life of Claudius Aelianus, known to us as Aelian. He was born sometime between A.D. 165 and 170 in the hill town of Praeneste, what is now Palestrina, about twenty-five miles from Rome, Italy. He grew up speaking that town’s version of Latin, a dialect that other speakers of the language seem to have found curious, but—somewhat unusually for his generation, though not for Romans of earlier times—he preferred to communicate in Greek. Trained by a sophist named Pausanias of Caesarea, Aelian was known in his time for a work called Indictment of the Effeminate, an attack on the recently deceased emperor Marcus Aurelius Antoninus, who was nasty even by the standards of Imperial Rome. He was also fond of making almanac-like collections, only fragments of which survive, devoted to odd topics such as manifestations of the divine and the workings of the supernatural.

His De Natura Animalium (On the Nature of Animals) has a similar patchwork quality, but it was esteemed enough in his time to survive more or less whole, and it is about all that we know of Aelian’s work today. A mostly randomly ordered collection of stories that he found interesting enough to relate about animals—whether or not he believed them—Aelian’s book constitutes an early encyclopedia of animal behavior, affording unparalleled insight into what ancient Romans knew about and thought about animals—and, of particular interest to modern scholars, about animal minds.

If the science is sometimes sketchy, the facts often fanciful, and the history sometimes suspect, it is clear enough that Aelian had a fine time assembling the material, which can be said, in the most general terms, to support the notion of a kind of intelligence in nature and that extends human qualities, for good and bad, to animals. His stories, which extend across the known world of Aelian’s time, tend to be brief and to the point, and many return to a trenchant question: If animals can respect their elders and live honorably within their own tribes, why must humans be so appallingly awful?

Aelian is as brisk, as entertaining, and as scholarly a writer as Pliny, the much better known Roman natural historian. That he is not better known is simply an accident: he has not been widely translated into English, or indeed any European language. This selection from his work will introduce readers to a lively mind and a witty writer who has much to tell us.

About Gregory McNamee

See more books from this Author
Gregory McNamee is a writer, journalist, editor, photographer, and consultant in publishing, film, and other media. He is the author or title-page editor of 30 books and more than 3,000 articles, essays, reviews, interviews, editorials, poems, and short stories. He is a consultant, contributor, and contributing editor to the Encyclopaedia Britannica and its blog, as well as a regular reviewer for Kirkus Reviews, a contributing editor to the Bloomsbury Review, and a correspondent for He is a research associate at the Southwest Center of the University of Arizona. He lives in Tucson.
Published August 31, 2012 by Trinity University Press. 180 pages
Genres: History, Education & Reference, Nature & Wildlife, Sports & Outdoors, Science & Math, Professional & Technical. Non-fiction
Add Critic Review

Critic reviews for Aelian's On the Nature of Animals
All: 1 | Positive: 0 | Negative: 1

WSJ online

Below average
Reviewed by Anthony Esolen on Feb 18 2012

My second quarrel is with an attitude prevalent in many contemporary books on nature. It isn't enough to enjoy the world about us, and delight in its beauty. No, we have to take one particular lesson...

Read Full Review of Aelian's On the Nature of Ani... | See more reviews from WSJ online

Rate this book!

Add Review