Atomic Obsession by John Mueller
Nuclear Alarmism from Hiroshima to Al-Qaeda

No critic rating

Waiting for minimum critic reviews

See 1 Critic Review

At times Mueller's attempts to deflate what he calls the "hype and hysteria" are reminiscent of Strangelovian scientists such as Edward Teller. But his attack on the post-9/11 alarmist rhetoric is welcome.


Following 9/11, Americans were swept up in a near hysteria-level fear of terrorists, especially of Islamic extremists working domestically. The government and media reports stoked fears that people living in the US have the desire and means to wreak extreme havoc and destruction. Early reports estimated slightly more than 300 al Qaeda operatives living in the United States. It wasn't long before this number became 2,000 or 5,000 domestic terrorists. As these estimates snowballed, so did spending on federal counterterrorism organizations and measures, spending which now totals over a trillion dollars. The federal government launched more covert operations in the name of fighting terrorist adversaries than they did in the entirety of the forty-five year Cold War. For each apprehension of a credible terrorist suspect, the US government created or re-organized two counterterrorism organizations. The scale of these efforts has been enormous, yet somehow they have not been proven to make Americans feels safe from what they perceive to be a massive terrorist threat. But how well-founded is this fear? Is the threat of terrorism in the United States as vast as it seems and are counterterrorism efforts effective and appropriately-scaled?

It has not, statistically speaking, been efficient or successful. Only one alarm in 10,000 has proven to be a legitimate threat-the rest are what the authors refer to as "ghosts." These ghosts are enormous drains on resources and contribute to a countrywide paranoia that has resulted in widespread support and minimal critical questioning of massive expenditures and infringements on civil liberties, including invasions of privacy and questionably legal imprisonments. In Chasing Ghosts, John Mueller and Mark Stewart argue that the "ghost chase" occupying American fears, law enforcement, and federal spending persists because the public believes that there exists in the US a dire and significant threat of terrorism. The authors seek to analyze to what degree this is a true and to what degree the threat posed by terrorists in the US defends the extraordinary costs currently put towards their investigation.

The chance that an American will be killed by a terrorist domestically in any given year is about one in four million (under present conditions). Yet despite this statistically low risk and the extraordinary amount of resources put towards combatting threats, Americans do not profess to feel any safer from terrorists. Until the true threat of domestic terrorism is analyzed and understood, the country cannot begin to confront whether our pursuit of ghosts is worth the cost.

About John Mueller

See more books from this Author
John Mueller is the Woody Hayes Chair of National Security Studies and Professor of Political Science, Ohio State University. He is the author of Overblown: How Politicians and the Terrorism Industry Inflate National Security Threats, and Why We Believe Them and The Remnants of War, winner of the Joseph P. Lepgold Prize for the best book on international relations in 2004, awarded by Georgetown University.
Published November 5, 2009 by Oxford University Press. 336 pages
Genres: History, Political & Social Sciences, War, Professional & Technical, Computers & Technology, Science & Math. Non-fiction
Add Critic Review

Critic reviews for Atomic Obsession
All: 1 | Positive: 1 | Negative: 0


Reviewed by PD Smith on May 01 2012

At times Mueller's attempts to deflate what he calls the "hype and hysteria" are reminiscent of Strangelovian scientists such as Edward Teller. But his attack on the post-9/11 alarmist rhetoric is welcome.

Read Full Review of Atomic Obsession: Nuclear Ala... | See more reviews from Guardian

Reader Rating for Atomic Obsession

An aggregated and normalized score based on 87 user ratings from iDreamBooks & iTunes

Rate this book!

Add Review