In America's Court by Thomas Geoghegan
How a Civil Lawyer Who Likes to Settle Stumbled into a Criminal Trial

No critic rating

Waiting for minimum critic reviews

See 2 Critic Reviews



A candid indictment of the American criminal justice system from the acclaimed author of Which Side Are You On? In previous books, including the widely praised labor history Which Side Are You On?, attorney Thomas Geoghegan has written with an insight and sensibility that enable him to use the smallest details of life as microcosms of larger truths. In In America's Court, Geoghegan's personal account of his experience with criminal law, he directs this sensibility toward a re-evaluation of his own career as a civil lawyer and a critique of the criminal justice system. When asked by a friend and public defender to assist with the defense in a criminal case, Geoghegan realizes that his twenty years as a prominent labor lawyer in civil court—where most arguments are made for quick settlement in the judge's quarters—have left him totally unprepared for the realities of criminal justice in the United States. Particularly when the case at hand is the defense of a twenty-two-year-old who, at the age of fifteen, was sentenced to forty years in prison for acting as the unarmed lookout in a botched burglary attempt. Suddenly Geoghegan must face the whims of jury selection, prosecutorial advantage, and the simple fact that the course of their client's life will be determined by the case. In America's Court is a candid indictment of a criminal justice system that, by routinely imprisoning minors, violates what the rest of the world considers to be all of our basic human rights. In addition, In America's Court is a call to lawyers to act with courage despite the frustrations of the profession. Geoghegan argues that there remain aspects of the law that are heroic and unbroken, and that, rather than civil or criminal law, the law of human rights should be supreme. Written in a uniquely ironic and personal style, In America's Court is a fascinating narrative of justice denied.

About Thomas Geoghegan

See more books from this Author
Thomas Geoghegan is a practicing attorney and the author of several books, including "Which Side Are You On?", which was a finalist for the National Book Critics Circle Award and received a special citation from the PEN/Martha Albrand Award judges. Geoghegan contributes regularly to "The American Prospect" and lives in Chicago.
Published July 1, 2002 by New Press, The. 206 pages
Genres: Education & Reference, Law & Philosophy. Non-fiction

Unrated Critic Reviews for In America's Court

Kirkus Reviews

See more reviews from this publication

But when the author trains his sharp mind on the ineffectiveness of the courts in, say, ending segregation, compared to the work of activists like Martin Luther King Jr., he makes a strong case that should resonate with everyone.

| Read Full Review of In America's Court: How a Civ...

Publishers Weekly

See more reviews from this publication

Likely he would choose the law again, he decides, even though it would be with profound reservations, because Geoghegan has not entirely lost faith in the liberal values he absorbed early on as a law student at Harvard.

| Read Full Review of In America's Court: How a Civ...

Reader Rating for In America's Court

An aggregated and normalized score based on 7 user ratings from iDreamBooks & iTunes

Rate this book!

Add Review