Notes from a Defeatist by Joe Sacco

No critic rating

Waiting for minimum critic reviews

See 2 Critic Reviews



A collection of comic book journalist Joe Sacco's best shorter pieces.

Before Joe Sacco crafted his two major works of "cartoon journalism," Palestine and Safe Area Gorazde, he created a number of shorter pieces, ranging from one-page gags to 30-page "graphic novelettes." This massive book finally collects the entirety of Sacco's earlier journalistic and autobiographical work, plus a sizable serving of his satirical strips, many of them never before collected in book form.

The centerpieces in Notes from a Defeatist are a triptych of war stories: "When Good Bombs Happen to Bad People," a history of aerial bombing that specifically targets civilian populations; "More Women, More Children, More Quickly," in which Sacco relates his mother's harrowing experiences during World War II in Malta; and, most personally (and closest to Sacco's later work), "How I Loved the War," Sacco's impassioned but sardonic reflection on the Gulf War, the surrounding propaganda and media circus, and his own ambivalent feelings as both a spectator and commentator: The book derives its title from this sequence, which has acquired a painful new relevance in the past half-year. Notes from a Defeatist also includes a roadie's-eye view of an American punk band's eventful European tour, a reminiscence of an awful season spent in his native Malta, and much more. Notes from a Defeatist is a fantastic primer to Sacco's work.

Sacco's previous two books, Safe Area Gorazde and Palestine, have earned international acclaim and accolades from such sources as Edward W. Said, Christopher Hitchens, Time, The New York Times Book Review, and The Washington Post. Black-and-white comics throughout

About Joe Sacco

See more books from this Author
Joe Sacco lives in Portland, Oregon. He is the author of many acclaimed graphic novels, including Palestine , Safe Area Gorazde , But I Like It , Notes from a Defeatist , The Fixer , War's End , and Footnotes in Gaza .
Published March 17, 2003 by Fantagraphics. 216 pages
Genres: Comics & Graphic Novels, Humor & Entertainment, Literature & Fiction, War. Fiction

Unrated Critic Reviews for Notes from a Defeatist

Publishers Weekly

See more reviews from this publication

This collection of early work by cartoonist/journalist Sacco, of American Book Award–winning Palestine and Safe Area Gorazde acclaim, assembles pieces ranging from early reportage to Sacco's young attempts at satire.

| Read Full Review of Notes from a Defeatist


Notes From a Defeatist is a collection of Joe Sacco's earlier work ("[p]art documentary travelogue, part satirical biography, part satire pure and simple" it says on the back) and, because of that, does not have the sustained power of a work like Palestine.

Jan 11 2003 | Read Full Review of Notes from a Defeatist

Rate this book!

Add Review