When We Were Orphans by Kazuo Ishiguro

No critic rating

Waiting for minimum critic reviews

See 7 Critic Reviews



British writer Kazuo Ishiguro won the 1989 Booker Prize for The Remains of the Day, which sold over a million copies in English alone and was the basis of a film starring Anthony Hopkins. Now When We Were Orphans, his extraordinary fifth novel, has been called “his fullest achievement yet” (The New York Times Book Review) and placed him again on the Booker shortlist. A complex, intelligent, subtle and restrained psychological novel built along the lines of a detective story, it confirms Ishiguro as one of the most important writers in English today. London’s Sunday Times said: “You seldom read a novel that so convinces you it is extending the possibilities of fiction.”

The novel takes us to Shanghai in the late 1930s, with English detective Christopher Banks bent on solving the mystery that has plagued him all his life: the disappearance of his parents when he was eight. By his own account, he is now a celebrated gentleman sleuth, the toast of London society. But as we learn, he is also a solitary figure, his career built on an obsession. Believing his parents may still be held captive, he longs to put right as an adult what he was powerless to change as a child, when he played at being Sherlock Holmes — before both his parents vanished and he was sent to England to be raised by an aunt.

Banks’ father was involved in the importation of opium, and solving the mystery means finding that his boyhood was not the innocent, enchanted world he has cherished in memory. The Shanghai he revisits is in the throes of the Sino—Japanese war, an apocalyptic nightmare; he sees the horror of the slums surrounding the international community in “a dreamscape worthy of Borges” (The Independent). “We think that if we can only put something right that went a bit awry, then our lives would be healed and the world would be healed,” says Ishiguro of the illusion under which his hero suffers.

It becomes increasingly clear that Banks is not to be trusted as a narrator. The stiff, elegant voice grows more hysterical, his vision more feverish, as he comes closer to the truth. Like Ryder of The Unconsoled, Ishiguro’s previous novel, Banks is trapped in his boyhood fantasy, and he follows his obsession at the cost of personal happiness. Other characters appear as projections of his fears and desires. All Ishiguro’s novels concern themselves with the past, the consequences of denying it and the unreliability of memory.

It is from Ishiguro’s own family history that the novel takes its setting. Though his family is Japanese, Ishiguro’s father was born in Shanghai’s international community in 1920; his grandfather was sent there to set up a Chinese branch of Toyota, then a textile company. “My father has old pictures of the first Mr. Toyota driving his Rolls-Royce down the Bund.” When the Japanese invaded in 1937, the fighting left the international commune a ghetto, and his family moved back to Nagasaki.

When We Were Orphans raises the bar for the literary mystery. Though more complex than much of Ishiguro’s earlier work, which has led to mixed reactions, it was published internationally (his work has been published in 28 languages) and was a New York Times bestseller.

About Kazuo Ishiguro

See more books from this Author
Kazuo Ishiguro is the author of five previous novels, including The Remains of the Day, which won the Booker Prize and became an international best seller. His work has been translated into twenty-eight languages. In 1995 he received an Order of the British Empire for service to literature, and in 1998 was named a Chevalier de l'Ordre des Arts et des Lettres by the French government. He lives in London with his wife and daughter.
Published January 16, 2001 by Vintage. 352 pages
Genres: Literature & Fiction, History, Mystery, Thriller & Suspense. Fiction

Unrated Critic Reviews for When We Were Orphans

Kirkus Reviews

See more reviews from this publication

every step taken toward recapturing his past confirms the indigenous axiom that “our childhood becomes like a foreign land once we have grown.” The disturbing climax, set in an unsettled urban hell far from the placid environs of the International Settlement, leads to a bitterly ironic revelation...

| Read Full Review of When We Were Orphans

BC Books

See more reviews from this publication

Many years later, Christopher Banks returns to a war-torn Shanghai to solve the mystery of his parents’ disappearance, which he does with unconvincing ease.

Feb 08 2009 | Read Full Review of When We Were Orphans

BC Books

See more reviews from this publication

Thankfully, for it could never have succeeded, Kazuo Ishiguro resists the temptation to offer any forensic evidence to support Christopher’s claim of talent in the area.

Feb 08 2009 | Read Full Review of When We Were Orphans

Book Reporter

He attended the best schools and set out to become a detective, the profession he always desired.It is this profession that brings him back to Shanghai 20 years later in an ardent and frantic attempt to uncover the mystery surrounding the disappearance of his parents and the role his Uncle Peter ...

Jan 24 2011 | Read Full Review of When We Were Orphans

Entertainment Weekly

The involuted detective novel When We Were Orphans — the fifth book from Kazuo Ishiguro, the author of The Remains of the Day — winds weirdly down the corridors of memory of its PI protagonist, Christopher Banks.

Sep 22 2000 | Read Full Review of When We Were Orphans

London Review of Books

Isherwood came to realise that the ‘appalling atmosphere of suburban Surrey’ masked dissipation: If you are using the site for the first time please register here If you would like access to all 12,000 articles subscribe here Institutions or university library users please login here Learn...

| Read Full Review of When We Were Orphans

Austin Chronicle

Just over 10 years ago, esteemed British novelist Kazuo Ishiguro published the novel for which he is best-known, The Remains of the Day.

Sep 29 2000 | Read Full Review of When We Were Orphans

Reader Rating for When We Were Orphans

An aggregated and normalized score based on 259 user ratings from iDreamBooks & iTunes

Rate this book!

Add Review

Reader reviews & activity

User Review

Brian Lee Kloosterman Jr. 17 Feb 2013

Rated the book as 3.5 out of 5