Reader Ratings: 4
Write a review
A bold and provocative study that presents language not as an innate component of the brain-as most linguists do-but as an essential tool unique to each culture worldwide. For years, the prevailing opinion among academics has been that language is embedded in our genes, existing as an innate and instinctual part of us. But linguist Daniel Everett argues that, like other tools, language was invented by humans and can be reinvented or lost. He shows how the... more
More problematic is that Everett emphasizes the “Culture” component of his “Cognition + Culture + Communication” formula to a point that misrepresents what human languages are.
Full ReviewDuring the heaviest going, he wades into academic discourse rather as an Amazon traveller might wade through a lagoon in the rainy season, stirring up more mud than clarity.
Full ReviewHis sketchy, disorganized treatment touches on neuroscience, linguistics, and information theory; most tellingly, he spotlights nativists’ failure to demonstrate that any meaningful universal grammar exists.
Full ReviewReaders’ eyes will sometimes sparkle with new insight, sometimes glaze at the dense exposition.
Full ReviewBut Mr Everett, in trying to reach a popular audience while making an argument aimed at professional linguists, makes some awkward compromises.
Full Review"Language: The Cultural Tool,” full of intellectually omnivorous insights and reminiscences about Everett’s years with the Pirahã...is that rare thing: a warm linguistics book.
Full Review